How we choose and rank ryokan
Last updated
- Who chooses
- What we look for
- The best lists and what each pick is named for
- How the full list in a place is ordered
- What it takes to be listed
1. Who chooses
Every “Best ryokan” list on this site is chosen by our editors and carries the date it was chosen. More about who we are is on the about page.
What we have not done: we have not stayed at every ryokan we list or name. A choice rests on what each ryokan states on its own pages, which we quote and keep on file, and on what its guests say in their ratings. Where a ryokan's pages don't say something, we don't either.
A place without our editors' selection has no “Best” list. Where it has a short list at all, it is headed “Top-ranked ryokan”: the top of the ranked order below, said to be just that.
2. What we look for
We judge a ryokan as a ryokan, on the things that make one stay unlike another. Each one we apply to a ryokan rests on a line from its own pages.
- The water
- Whether the baths are hot-spring water, whether it flows straight from the source without being recirculated, and whether there is a bath in your room. A city ryokan with a good wooden tub of tap water can still be among the best; we say which it is.
- Dinner
- Whether dinner is served, what kind (a kaiseki course or a simpler meal) and where: in your room, in a private room or in a dining hall. A ryokan that serves breakfast only is judged on everything else.
- The building and its age
- When the ryokan was founded, and whether the building is registered as national heritage.
- Scale
- How many rooms it has. A ryokan of a dozen rooms is a different stay from one of a hundred.
- Setting
- Where it is: on the river, in the old town, a short walk from the station or the sights.
- Recognition
- Whether a guide we trust recognises it: Michelin Keys, membership of Relais & Châteaux, or national heritage registration. Each one is confirmed on the awarding body's own page and shown with its year.
- Who it suits
- Adults only or families welcome, tattoos in the shared baths, a first ryokan stay or a tenth.
Recognition we name
We name recognition from a short list of awards and registers: Michelin Keys, Relais & Châteaux, national heritage registration of the building. Each one shown is checked on the awarding body's own page and shown with its year. Where the awarding body gives no year, as with Relais & Châteaux membership, we show the year we last confirmed it (“checked 2026”); awards are given again each year, so we check them again too. Recognition is a reason to look closely, never the source of a fact about the ryokan: those come from the ryokan's own pages. We don't name awards from booking or review sites.
3. The best lists and what each pick is named for
A best list names up to six ryokan, in our editors' order. Each is named for one thing it does best, from the set below, with a line on why and one honest trade-off. A category is given only where a quoted line from the ryokan supports it.
- Best for a first ryokan stay
- Needs dinner and breakfast served at the ryokan, a bath to soak in, and an easy way there.
- Heritage
- Needs a founding year before 1950, or a national heritage registration.
- Open-air hot-spring bath in the room
- Needs an open-air bath of hot-spring water in the room.
- For the water
- Needs hot-spring water that flows straight from the source.
- For dinner
- Needs a kaiseki or named-cuisine dinner, and where it is served.
- Small and quiet
- Needs 15 rooms or fewer.
- Value
- Needs dinner and breakfast at or under the middle price of the place.
- Tattoo-friendly
- Needs tattoos allowed in the shared baths.
- For sightseeing
- Needs a short walk to a station or the sights, in a city.
- For couples
- Needs adults only, or a bath in every room.
- Ryokan we can't sell are included. If the best ryokan in a place is one we can't book, it is on the list, marked “Not bookable with us”.
- What we earn plays no part. Whether we can sell a ryokan, and what we would earn if you book it, are not considered.
- A city ryokan can be among the best. A wooden tub of tap water, or breakfast only, does not rule a ryokan out; we say which it is.
A ryokan missing from a best list has not been judged worse. We may not have researched it yet, or its pages may not state what we would need.
4. How the full list in a place is ordered
Below any best list, every destination page lists all its stays in one ranked order. The order comes from a score built the same way for every stay in every place, from four measures. It is a ranking, not a recommendation.
- 35%How sought-after it is
- How often people in the US search for the ryokan by name each month. Where we have no search figure, its number of guest reviews stands in, and counts for less.
- 30%Guest rating
- Its average guest score out of 10. A score from only a few reviews is pulled toward the average for its area, so a handful of perfect scores can't outrank hundreds of good ones.
- 20%The kind of stay
- A ryokan scores above a minshuku or a machiya, and those score above an onsen hotel. An onsen on site and dinner served on site each add to it.
- 15%Whether you can book it
- On how many of our sample dates we found a room to sell, for one night for two adults.
- Price mix. If none of the first ten in a place is at or below that place's middle price, the best-scoring stay that is moves up to tenth, so the top of a list is never only its most expensive ryokan.
- Your dates. Once you set dates, stays with a room for them come first and the rest follow, each group still in ranked order.
- Top-ranked lists. Where a page has no best list of our editors', it may open with the first six ryokan in this order that we have researched, none left out, under “Top-ranked ryokan”. On a page that covers a whole region, no more than two come from any one town.
- Lists that cross places. The national lists (all ryokan, private onsen, onsen hotels) put the stays we have written a full page for first, then the rest by guest rating, steadied the same way against small numbers of reviews.
Guest ratings are the scores guests left after staying, shown as we receive them from our booking partner. The ranking counts whether we can book a stay, and it is the smallest of the four measures; how much we earn on a booking is not in it.
5. What it takes to be listed
We list 4,089 places to stay. Each was checked against these rules, and each is labelled as the type it is.
- A ryokan is a staffed lodging, not a self-catering rental; its rooms are mainly tatami; and it calls itself a ryokan or sells stays per person with dinner and breakfast. A booking site calling something a ryokan is where we start, not proof.
- A minshuku (民宿, a small family-run inn) or a pension is listed only when most of its rooms are Japanese-style, and is never counted as a ryokan.
- A machiya (a rented townhouse) is listed as a machiya, never as a ryokan.
- A hotel is listed only as an onsen hotel, in its own section and never among the ryokan. Chain hotels are decided brand by brand.
- Never listed: guest houses, hostels and backpacker lodgings, whatever they call their rooms.
Being listed is not a recommendation, and there is no rating bar to get in. Most places we list are ones you can book through us; a few well-known ryokan we can't book have a full page of their own.
A smaller set of well-known ryokan have a page written by hand, answering the same nine questions in the same words, which our editors read and sign off. How each answer is checked against the ryokan's own pages is set out in How we verify ryokan.
How this fits with how we earn
We earn money when you book a stay through this site. It plays no part in the best lists. In the ranked order, whether we can book a stay is one measure of four and the smallest. If you think a ryokan is listed as the wrong type, or named on a wrong fact, tell us through the contact page and we'll check it.