Ryokan Society

How we verify ryokan

Last updated

The details that decide a ryokan stay, such as whether the bath is in your room or whether you can bathe with a tattoo, are often written only on the ryokan's own Japanese pages. This page sets out how we decide what to list and how each detail on a ryokan page is checked.

What counts as a ryokan

We list a property as a ryokan when it meets all three: it is a staffed lodging, not a self-catering rental; its rooms are mainly tatami (beds on tatami are fine); and it calls itself a ryokan (旅館 or 宿) or sells stays per person with dinner and breakfast. Whether it has its own hot-spring bath is a separate question, shown on each listing. A booking site's “ryokan” label is a starting point, not proof. The rules for every other type of stay, the order of each list and the “best” lists are in How we choose and rank ryokan.

The same nine answers on every page

Every ryokan page we write by hand answers the same nine questions, in the same order and the same words, so two ryokan can be compared line by line:

  1. Shared baths
  2. Bath in your room
  3. Private bath
  4. Tattoos
  5. Meals
  6. Dietary needs
  7. Children
  8. Check-in
  9. Getting there

No quote, no answer

  • Every answer rests on a quoted line. Behind each answer our records keep the exact line it comes from, copied word for word and usually in Japanese, the address of the page it is on, and the date we read it.
  • The page must be the ryokan's. A source counts only when its name, and its address or phone number, match the ryokan's own site.
  • The ryokan's own site comes first. We use a booking site's listing only where the ryokan's own pages are silent.
  • A missing line is not a no. We answer “No” only when a line says so, or when a complete list of the ryokan's facilities leaves it out. When we searched and found nothing, the page says “Not stated by the ryokan” instead of guessing.
  • Nothing is carried over unchecked. A detail from notes or an earlier pass is read again at its source. If no line there says it, it becomes “Not stated by the ryokan”.
  • Answers can't say more than the evidence. Automated checks fail the page if, for example, it says every room has a bath when the evidence covers only some, or calls water hot-spring water without a line saying so.

Which bath you can use

Open-air bath in room 露天風呂付き客室
An outdoor hot-spring or heated bath belonging to your room type.
Bath in your room 内風呂
An indoor bath in your room type, filled from the hot spring or heated.
Bookable private bath 貸切風呂
A bath you reserve for a set time; it is not in your room.
Shared baths only 大浴場
Public baths, usually separated by gender.

Meals: what you can book

A ryokan may sell several plans on its own site. The meal plans we show come from the live rates we sell, because those are the plans you can actually book here. If every rate we can sell includes dinner and breakfast, the page says so. The ryokan's own pages still give the details, such as how dinner is served and where.

Where each ryokan is on the map

Every map pin comes from a named source: our booking partner's catalogue, Wikidata, the ryokan's official address, or the pin on its own access page. Where a second source exists we compare the two, and any disagreement of more than 300 metres is resolved by hand and recorded. Coordinates are never typed in from memory.

Checked by a person

Quoted facts are checked by hand in samples against their source pages. Every ryokan page we write by hand is read and signed off by our editors before search engines are allowed to index it, and comes back for review when it changes materially.

What we don't claim

Unless a page says otherwise, what we publish comes from the ryokan's published pages and from our booking partner's live rates, not from a stay or a phone call. We don't invent ratings, and we don't fill a gap with what is usual for ryokan.

Prices per person

Ryokan usually charge per person per night with dinner and breakfast included (1泊2食付き), where a hotel quotes a room. Compare the total for your whole party and what it includes, not the headline figure.

Found a mistake?

Tell us through the contact page and we'll check it against the source. More about who we are and how the site earns money is on the about page.